Many older people live unhappily in residential settings that are designed to help them. How can you help a resident who is unhappy, has lost interest in life, or has become testy and difficult? The following example is about one of the lucky few who can afford to live in a high-quality CCRC and who has a devoted family. Still, his story can help us explore some options.
THE STORY OF SAMUEL G
After serving in WWII, Samuel became a lawyer. He married and put his three children through college, gave them down payments for their houses and later paid for his grandchildren’s college educations.
His wife’s parents and his father died without becoming disabled. His mother, however, developed severe dementia. Samuel and his wife kept her at home, but eventually found it too difficult and moved her to a nursing home. It was well-run, clean and had caring staff. But the room she shared with a series of strangers was small; she could keep only a few mementos of her long life. She became depressed, turned increasingly inward and was miserable when she died. To avoid this fate, Samuel and his wife signed up for a CCRC where they could live independently as long as possible, could move to assisted living when necessary and go to the nursing home only as a last resort.
Sadly, his wife died shortly after they moved in. Despite his great loss, Samuel maintained many friendships, was active on various committees and visited his children and grandchildren frequently until he was about 90. Then memory loss began to limit his abilities. For several years he continued to live in his own apartment, went out for meals and activities on his own and managed his medications with help from the onsite clinic. But when the bills went unpaid, his daughter took over his finances. He had to give up driving and needed more reminders for meals and medications. Although he enjoyed calls and visits from his children and grandchildren, he rarely remembered specific conversations or what they did. The staff and his children became concerned that he was becoming isolated and not eating enough. Samuel eventually moved to assisted living where he had a room spacious enough for many of his most treasured possessions, not at all like the nursing home where his mother died.
In the beginning his old friends from independent living visited him and some invited him to dinner, but this diminished over time. He had not made new friends on the “memory unit.” He usually stays alone in his room. He could go out, but was a bit frightened to go off alone and offended that he had to sign in and out under the watchful eye of a staff member. At mealtimes he went to the unit dining room, greeting people with a smile and a simple pleasantry, but not really remembering who they are. He ate mostly in silence.
Sometimes he participated in group activities, but most often felt that the “activities” were for people much more disabled than him. He did go to theatre or concerts when the residence arranged trips. However, he rarely remembered the specifics of the events after returning home, but did retain the emotions they evoked.
Staff members brought him his medication several times a day. He does not remember what medications were and sometimes insists that the doctor explain why he needs them. He also forgot that the doctor or nurse practitioner had already done so. His angry insistence annoyed the staff. They saw him as “difficult,” “unpleasant” or even “nasty.” Increasingly, he spent his days in his room reading books he enjoyed but cannot remember, often reading the same page over and over again.
When he was younger, Samuel was an avid reader both for work and for pleasure. He particularly liked political history. He also followed the Yankees carefully and had known all the players’ names and stats. He loved comedy improv; his loud belly laugh made him one of those people comics love to have in the audience. But in the assisted living facility, he rarely laughed anymore. In fact, he didn’t seem to get any joy out of life except when his grandchildren visited. Everyone felt sorry for Samuel and wanted to help him enjoy the last years of his life, but they didn’t know what to do.
This sad scenario can be rewritten by using creative approaches to combating unhappiness in the LTC setting. Addressing Samuel’s needs in a personalized approach can improve his mood and his quality of life.
TREATING MENTAL ILLNESS
Think about unhappiness from the perspective of mental illness. Samuel, for example, is sad, bored and irritable—all symptoms of a major depressive disorder (MDD). Referral to a mental health professional for an assessment and treatment makes a great deal of sense. In general, mental health training for the staff of residential facilities, routine screening and easy access to good mental health assessment and treatment are critical components of long-term care.
It is also possible to approach Samuel’s unhappiness not as an illness but as a reflection of his current life situation. He is lonely, bored and feels demeaned; each can be addressed directly.